Hypocrisy penalty: Investors especially hate companies that say they’re good then behave badly – unless the money is good

Stock investors punish companies caught doing something unethical a lot more when when these businesses also have a record of portraying themselves as virtuous. This hypocrisy penalty is the main finding of a study we recently published in the Journal of Management.

Companies often espouse their supposed virtue – known as ‘virtue signaling’ – usually with the aim of getting benefits, such as higher sales, positive investor sentiment or better employees. We wanted to know what happens when such companies then do something wrong.

So we examined corporate communications and media coverage for every company in the Standard & Poor’s 500 . . .

Enjoy access to this and more – for free!

Log in or create your free My IR – Essentials account to:

  • Get access to 3 free IR deep dives
  • More than 100 pieces of insight, plus our exclusive CFO interviews
  • Save favorites and get personalized content on your dashboard
  • Enjoy 10% off all IR forums

Upcoming events

  • Awards – Europe
    Thursday, June 18, 2026

    Awards – Europe

    About the event The IR Impact Awards – Europe takes place on Thursday, June 18, 2026 in London. This very special event honors excellence in the investor relations profession across Europe and we are excited to welcome everyone for an evening of fine food and lots of celebrating! WHEN WHERE…

    London, UK
  • Think Tank – Europe
    Thursday, June 18, 2026

    Think Tank – Europe

    About the event The IR Impact Think Tank – Europe will take place on Thursday, June 18, 2026 in London and exclusively for senior IR officers. Our think tanks are free to attend and our unique format enables participants to network extensively, discuss, debate and dissect topical issues affecting today’s…

    London, UK
  • Forum – AI & Technology
    Thursday, November 12, 2026

    Forum – AI & Technology

    About the event As more investors and corporate communication teams embrace AI, machine learning and emerging technologies to inform their decision making, investor relations professionals are facing a pivotal moment: adapt and lead, or risk falling behind. At this fast-moving stage of adoption, IR teams are asking important questions regarding…

    New York, US

Explore

Andy White, Freelance WordPress Developer London